MIlwaukee Menu
*Pizza Man Favorites | GF - Gluten-Free | V - Vegetarian | V+ - Vegan | Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, eggs or unpasteurized milk may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
Starters
Garlic Bread (V)
$6.00
Marinara | Add Wisconsin mozzarella cheese +$2.00
*Eggplant Fries (V)
$8.00/+
Buttermilk-marinated, creamy parmesan dressing, marinara | Small $8 or large $12
Buttermilk Haystack Onion Strings (V)
$6.00/+
Parmesan and herb dusting, served with creamy parmesan sauce. Small $6 or large $10
Meatball Marinara
$9.00/+
House-made meatballs made of ground beef Vinny’s Italian sausage, and marinara, served with crostinis Small (3) for $9 or large (6) for $15
Crispy Brussels Sprouts (GF)
$12.00
Bacon, American Grana Padano, Calabrian chili honey, herbs
Parmesan Truffle Fries (V)
$12.00
Truffle aïoli, parmesan, sea salt
Wonton Wrapped Mozzarella Sticks (V)
$7.00/+
Marinara | order of 3 for $7, 6 for $11, or 9 for $16
Crispy Calamari
$14.00
Pepperoncini, marinara
Pizza Man Sampler (V)
$16.00
Buttermilk haystack onion strings, wonton mozzarella sticks, eggplant fries, served with marinara, parmesan sauce, and pesto ranch.
Salads
Add Grilled Chicken +$5.00 | Crispy Chicken +6.00
*Shaved Brussels Sprouts (V, GF)
$9.00
$13.00
Arugula, Door County dried cherries, ricotta salata, toasted hazelnuts, charred lemon vinaigrette
Chopped
$9.00
$13.00
Seasonal greens, salami, garbanzo beans, Kalamata and Castelvetrano olives, celery smoked provolone, cucumber, red onion, tomato, red wine vinaigrette
Oakland Ave Caesar
$8.00
$12.00
Romaine, parmesan, garlic bread crouton, original Pizza Man Caesar dressing.
Garden (V)
$7.00
$10.00
Seasonal greens, crouton, cucumber, pickled carrots, red onion, tomato, herb ranch dressing
Sandwiches
Served with a choice of fries or a side salad. Sub Parmesan Truffle Fries +$2, Sub Crispy Brussels Sprouts +$3
Meatball Hero
$13.00
Mozzarella, marinara, creamy giardiniera spread, basil, parmesan, Italian sesame bread.
Chicken Parmesan
$14.00
Italian breaded chicken breast, mozzarella, marinara, basil, parmesan, Italian sesame bread.
C.B.R.
$14.00
Grilled chicken breast, ranch, bacon, tomato, cheddar, lettuce, red onion, Italian sesame bread.
Chopped Italian
$13.00
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, olives, celery, provolone, mozzarella, salami, sopressata, prosciutto, parmesan, red wine vinaigrette, Italian sesame bread.
Eggplant Grinder (V)
$13.00
Crispy eggplant, mozzarella, marinara, basil, parmesan, Italian sesame bread.
Hot Italian
$13.00
Vinny’s spicy Italian sausage, marinara, bell peppers, yellow onion, mozzarella, basil, parmesan, and Italian sesame bread.
Pasta
Sub gluten-free spaghetti +2 | add a side salad +4
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$19.00
Italia red sauce, parmesan, herbs.
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
$21.00
Garlic cream sauce, parmesan.
Chicken Parmesan
$20.00
Italian red sauce, spaghetti, fresh mozzarella, parmesan.
Spicy Rigatoni a La Vodka
$19.00
Vodka sauce, Vinny’s Italian sausage, Calabrian peppers, parmesan.
Specialty Pizza
Small 12” | Medium 14” | Large 16” | All pizzas are created with Wisconsin mozzarella. Our fermented thin cracker crust is prepared in-house. Our specialty pizzas have been designed and crafted by our Pizza Man chefs. They are meant to be enjoyed as-is. Please limit modifications to two per specialty pizza | Sauce It Up for +$ 1: Marinara, Pesto Ranch, Creamy Parmesan, Herbed Buttermilk Ranch, Calabrian Hot Honey, Truffle Aioli, Honey BBQ
Pizza Man Special
$21.00/12"
$23.00/14"
$27.00/16"
Classic sauce, pepperoni, Vinny’s Italian sausage, green pepper, yellow onion, mushroom, black olive
*Milwaukee
$18.00/12"
$20.00/14"
$24.00/16"
Classic sauce, Vinny’s Italian sausage, mushroom, yellow onion
Carnivoro
$20.00/12"
$22.00/14"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, pepperoni, garlic sausage, Canadian bacon
*Bianca (V)
$18.00/12"
$20.00/14"
$24.00/16"
Garlic cream sauce, cream cheese, mushroom, truffle oil, American Grana Padano, arugula
Veggie Supreme (V)
$18.00/12"
$22.00/14"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, black olive, grape tomato, green pepper, mushroom, yellow onion
Pizza Man Margherita (V)
$19.00/12"
$21.00/14"
$24.00/16"
Italia red sauce, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, EVOO
BBQ Chicken
$19.00/12"
$22.00/14"
$25.00/16"
BBQ sauce, cheddar, grilled chicken, cream cheese, red onion, pickled banana pepper, cilantro
Pesto Pig
$20.00/12"
$22.00/14"
$25.00/16"
Basil pesto, pancetta, red wine-pickled onion, goat cheese, fried basil, oven-roasted tomato
Atomica
$20.00/12"
$22.00/14"
$25.00/16"
Italia red sauce, spicy soppressata, prosciutto, Calabrian pepper, oregano, red onion, smoked provolone
Hawaiian
$19.00/12"
$21.00/14"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, Canadian bacon, caramelized pineapple, cream cheese
King - Roni
$19.00/12"
$21.00/14"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, pepperoni cups, diced pepperoni, pepperoni, American Grana Padano, chili flake, oregano
Topher
$18.00/12"
$20.00/14"
$24.00/16"
Classic sauce, garlic sausage, Calabrian chili honey, cream cheese, pickled jalapeño
Artichoke A La Mode (V)
$19.00/12"
$21.00/14"
$24.00/16"
Classic sauce, artichoke, tomato, chopped garlic, basil, cream cheese
Build Your Own
Small 12” | Medium 14” | Large 16”
The Orginal Thin Crust
$13.00/12"
$15.00/14"
$17.00/16"
Vegan Cauliflower Crust (V+, GF)
$17.00/10"
Choose Your Sauce:
Classic Sauce (V+) | Italia Red Sauce (V+) | Garlic Cream Sauce (V) | Basil Pesto (V) | BBQ sauce (V+)
Choose Your Toppings:
Prices are per topping. All Build-Your-Own pizzas are created with Wisconsin mozzarella
Premium Topping:
$3.00
$4.00
$5.50
Meatball, Prosciutto, Soppressata, Pancetta
Proteins:
$2.00
$3.00
$5.00
Anchovies, Bacon, BBQ Confit Chicken, Canadian Bacon, Genoa Salami, Grilled Chicken, Pepperoni, Pepperoni Cups, Pepperoni Diced, Vinny’s Italian Sausage
Cheeses:
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
Wisconsin mozzarella, Cheddar, Cream cheese, Fresh mozzarella, Goat cheese, Smoked provolone, Parmesan
Veggies:
$1.50
$2.00
$2.50
Artichoke, Arugula, Black Olive, Calabrian Pepper, Castelvetrano Olive, Chopped Garlic, Fresh Basil, Fresh Oregano, Grape tomato, Green pepper, Grilled pineapple, Kalamata olives, Mushroom, Pickled banana pepper, Pickled jalapeńo, Red wine pickled onion, Red onion, Spicy giardiniera, Spinach, Yellow onion
Desserts
Seasonal Cheesecake (V)
$8.00
Ask your server for seasonal toppings.
Tiramisu (V)
$8.00
Espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cheese, shaved chocolate
Italian Gelato (V, GF)
$6.00
Vanilla, chocolate, and salted caramel
Wine
WHITE, ROSE & SPARKLING WINE BY THE BOTTLE:
Chateau Buena Vista
$52.00/bottle
Chardonnay | 2020 | Carneros, CA
Tormaresca Neprica
$40.00/bottle
Chardonnay | 2022 | Southern Italy
Sassoregale
$43.00/bottle
Vermentino | 2020 | Toscana, Italy
Chateau de Campuget
$40.00/bottle
Rosé | 2022 | Rhone Valley, France
Terra d’Oro
$45.00/bottle
Chenin Blanc | 2021 | Clarksburg, CA
Dry Creek Vineyard
$50.00/bottle
Chenin Blanc | 2021 | Sonoma, CA
Colli Euganei
$48.00/bottle
Pinot Grigio | 2022 | Veneto, Italy
Mionetto
$50.00/bottle
Prosecco Brut | Veneto, Italy
Emmolo
$45.00/bottle
Sauvignon Blanc | 2022 | North Coast, CA
Bottega Vinaia
$54.00/bottle
Pinot Grigio | 2021 | Trentino, Italy
Rainstorm
$40.00/bottle
Pinot Gris | Willamette Valley, OR
The Beach by Whispering Angel
$50.00/bottle
Rosé | 2022 | Provence, France
Rutherford Hill
$75.00/bottle
Sauvignon Blanc | 2022 | Napa Valley, CA
Fazi Battaglia
$42.00/bottle
Verdicchio | 2020 | Marche, Italy
Dr. Loosen
$50.00/bottle
Riesling | 2021 | Mosel, Germany
La Gioiosa
$42.00/bottle
Moscato | 2021 | Veneto, Italy
RED WINE BY THE BOTTLE:
Robert Mondavi
$68.00/bottle
Cabernet | 2019 | Napa Valley, CA
Rutherford Hill
$110.00/bottle
Cabernet | 2016 | Napa Valley, CA
Caymus
$150.00/bottle
Cabernet | 2020 | Napa Valley, CA
Chimney Rock
$215.00/bottle
Cabernet | 2019 | Napa Valley, CA
Légende
$52.00/bottle
Bordeaux Blend | 2020 | Bordeaux, France
Achaval Ferrer
$68.00/bottle
Malbec | 2020 | Argentina
Puianello Amabile
$42.00/bottle
Lambrusco Rosso | Northern Italy
Pendulum
$54.00/bottle
Red Blend | 2021 | Columbia Valley, WA
Sixth Sense
$58.00/bottle
Syrah | 2020 | Lodi, CA
Ruffino Modus
$54.00/bottle
Toscana | 2019 | Tuscany, Italy
Orin Swift 8 Years in the Dessert
$105.00/bottle
Zinfandel Blend | 2021 | CA
Caymus Conundrum
$68.00/bottle
Red Blend | 2020 | Napa Valley, CA
Carpinteto Dogajolo
$50.00/bottle
Sangiovese Blend | 2020 | Tuscany, Italy
Citto
$55.00/bottle
Red Blend | 2020 | Tuscany, Italy
Campo Veijo
$54.00/bottle
Tempranillo | 2021 | Rioja, Spain
Cecchi
$60.00/bottle
Chianti | 2021 | Tuscany, Italy
Pertinace
$56.00/bottle
Nebbiolo | 2020 | Langhe, Italy
Rutherford Hill
$85.00/bottle
Merlot | 2021 | Napa Valley, CA
Banshee
$56.00/bottle
Pinot Noir | 2021 | Sonoma, CA
Portillo
$40.00/bottle
Pinot Noir | 2021 | Argentina
TAP WINE:
WHITES:
Le Contesse Frizzante
$7.00/glass
$30.00/carafe
Dry Prosecco | Veneto, Italy
Prastch Rosé
$9.00/glass
$38.00/carafe
Dry Peach & Berry | Austria
Tiamo Pinot Grigio
$8.00/glass
$34.00/carafe
Crisp & Light-Bodied | Italy
Wither Hills Sauvignon Blanc
$10.00/glass
$44.00/carafe
Bright & Citrusy | New Zealand
Pine Ridge Chenin Blanc + Viognier
$10.00/glass
$42.00/carafe
Medium- Bodied & Crisp | Napa Valley, CA
Seaglass Chardonnay
$10.00/glass
$42.00/carafe
Un-Oaked | Santa Barbara, CA
REDS:
Stemmari Pinot Noir
$10.00/glass
$42.00/carafe
Elegant & Bright | Sicily, Italy
MonVin Sangiovese
$10.00/glass
$42.00/carafe
Dry & Fruity | Central Italy
Seghisio Zinfandel
$13.00/glass
$52.00/carafe
Juicy & Earthy | Sonoma County, CA
Angeline Cabernet Sauvignon
$11.00/glass
$44.00/carafe
Full-bodied | Russian River Valley, CA
Freakshow Cabernet Sauvignon
$13.00/glass
$52.00/carafe
Flavorful & Robust | Central Valley, CA
Bodini Malbec
$9.00/glass
$38.00/carafe
Dark Fruit & Spice | Argentina
Beer
TAP BEER:
Blake’s “Original”
$8.00
Classic Apple Cider | 5.5% ABV | Armada, MI
Third Space “Cranberry Gose”
$8.00
Fruited Gose | 4.5% ABV | Milwaukee, WI
Peroni Pilsner
$6.00
Italian Pilsner | 4.8% ABV | Italy
Good City “Motto”
$6.00
Pale Ale | 5.2% ABV | Milwaukee, WI
Third Space “Smile”
$6.00
Wheat Ale | 4.8% ABV | Milwaukee, WI
New Glarus “Spotted Cow”
$6.00
Farmhouse Ale | 4.8% ABV | New Glarus, WI
One Barrel “Ninja Dust”
$7.00
New England IPA | 6.5% ABV | Madison, WI
Foxtown “Pizza Man Pale Ale”
$7.00
Hazy IPA | 5% ABV | Mequon, WI
Potosi “Snake Hollow”
$7.00
Midwest IPA | 6.5% ABV | Potosi, WI
Badger State “Grassy Place”
$8.00
Hazy IPA | 6.7% ABV | Green Bay, WI
Foxtown “Brick Oven”
$6.00
Amber l 5.2% ABV l Mequon, WI
3 Sheeps “Rebel Kent”
$7.00
Amber | 5% ABV | Sheboygan, WI
Mobcraft “BatSh*t Crazy”
$8.00
Coffee Brown Ale | 5.6% ABV | Sheboygan, WI
Hinterland “Maple Bock”
$7.00
Bock Ale | 6% ABV | Green Bay, WI
Central Waters “Mudpuppy”
$7.00
Porter l 5.6% ABV l Amherst, WI
Guinness
$6.00
Nitro Irish Stout l 4.2% ABV
BOTTLES & CANS:
Coors Lite
$6.00/16oz can
Domestic
Miller Lite
$6.00/12oz bottle
Domestic
PBR
$6.00/16oz can
Domestic
Lakefront Extended Play
$6.00
Non-Alcoholic Pale Ale
Truly Seltzers
$6.00
Flavors: Pineapple | Wild Berry
Odell - Sippin' Tropical
$7.00
Sour Ale w/ Pineapple | Passionfruit | Tangerine | 4.5% ABV
Lakefront - Riverwest Stein
$7.00
Amber Lager | 5.7% ABV
Shiner Bock
$6.00
German Malt Lager | 4.4% ABV
Cocktails
TAP COCKTAILS:
Paloma Aperol Spritz
$10.00
Blanco Tequila | Aperol | Grapefruit | Lime Juice
Cherry Lime Mojito
$10.00
White Rum | Filthy Cherries Juice | Lime Juice | Simple Syrup | Mint
Honey Bourbon Sour
$10.00
Jim Beam | Honey Simple | Lemon | Lime
Red Sangria
$10.00/glass
$38.00/pitcher
Seasonal Red Wine | Triple Sec | Cinnamon Liqueur | Lemon Juice
SPECIALTY COCKTAILS:
Raspberry Lemon Drop
$11.00
Chambord | Bacardi Limon | Lemon Juice | Simple Syrup
Mango Mule
$10.00
Smirnoff Vodka | Mango Purée | Lime Juice | Ginger Beer
Pizza Man Old Fashioned
$13.00
Maker's Mark | Honey Simple | Bitters | Cherry | Orange
Italian Margarita
$12.00
Casamigos Reposado | Amaretto | Lime Juice | Triple Sec
Fleur Fizz
$13.00
Rehorst Gin | Tattersall Crème de Fleur | Lemon Juice | Simple Syrup | Prosecco
Humboldt Spritz
$12.00
Tattersal Cranberry | Sweet Vermouth | Prosecco
MOCKTAILS:
Mango "Margarita"
$7.00
Mango Puree | Lime Juice | Sour Mix
Grapefruit Tart
$6.00
Lime Juice | Simple Syrup | Grapefruit Juice | Soda
Pineapple Faux - Jito
$8.00
Pineapple Juice | Fresh Mint | Sprite
Spiced Lemonade
$8.00
Cayenne Rosemary Simple Syrup | Lemonade
Non - Alcoholic Beverages
Sprecher Soda
$5.00
Root Beer | Orange Dream | Cream Soda
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
$4.00/500 ml
$8.00/1 l
San Pellegrino Flavored Sparkling Water
$4.50
Aranciata Rosso (Blood Orange) | Limonata (Lemon)
Coke
$3.50
Diet Coke
$3.50
Sprite
$3.50
Iced Tea
$4.00
Lemonade
$4.00
Cranberry Juice
$4.50
Apple Juice
$4.50
Grapefruit Juice
$4.50
Orange Juice
$4.50
Pineapple Juice
$4.50
Stone Creek Coffee
$3.50
Regular | Decaf